05 December 2023

Emotion versus Reason

 Emotion versus Reason

Stimulated by some words in Meeting on Sunday, I recalled that I preferred sorting disputes by recourse to reason, rather than emotion. This strong preference of mine emerged during the period around the break-up of my marriage. In many soliloquies I had silently verbalised my preference thus: suppose one party wants this and the other party wants that, how can they  negotiate, short of 'giving-in'? How can they each know the strength of the other's wanting? It seemed to me that the best way forward was to seek reasons and arguments; talk, therefore, in terms of money, time, resources, where numbers could be put on the strengths of each case. I suspect I still feel that reason is my preferred way out of an emotional conflict. 

However, as I made my way home from Meeting, two further realisations flooded over me.
[1] I have been on a number of training courses on 'Conciliation'. I understand the nub of the technique to be that each party is brought to see very clearly the emotional impact of the problem at issue on the other party. Thus, with the two contestants (A & B) and the conciliator (C) in a protected ('safe') arena, A and then B each explain to C their case, and how they feel. Conflicts that matter are conflicts of emotions. (Conflicts over facts are easily resolved, as Father showed us children: you can force it to an issue by offering a 6-penny bet on your favoured outcome, then you 'look-up' the answer.)
[2] It occurred to me that I was essentially admitting an inability to assess either my own emotions, or those of other people with whom I interact; or of both parties. This is close to admitting to  'Asperger's Syndrome', which I understand as a deficit in the ability to read the emotional significance of the observable actions of other people. It is very hard to know, as I had always assumed myself to be 'standard'. But perhaps I am deficient! 

I can certainly see the observable actions (or think I can). Nor do I think of myself as lacking emotions; the opposite rather, for I weep with joy when I see kindness, and I feel contaminated when protagonists in a drama tell a lie. But I might be suppressing my emotions, shuffling them out of (conscious) sight, precisely because they are too painful. 

How can I test that possibility?  Any such attempt sounds like a recipe for noise and stress. Perhaps I shall continue with my present strategies. 

03 December 2023

Life after Death

 Life after Death

    I think there is some truth in maintaining that of the many claims made on behalf of Christianity, the one chiefly responsible for it becoming the world's 'most-followed' religion, was its promise of  'Life after Death'. (A feature it shares with Islam, the 'second biggest' religion.)  Yet how can any sane person believe "the resurection of the dead, in the flesh"? And did Jesus himself believe in that?

    The idea that something, the soul or core or essence of a person, could survive death seems to be irresistibly comforting to the human psyche. It was widely discussed in the Middle East long before Jesus. To Plato, writing some 400 years before the birth of Jesus, the essence of a table was not the table itself, the hard fact; it was the idea of a table [1]. The essential table might exist in the mind of God. So, a Platonist might think that the essence of Mr. Harold Blum existed in the mind of God independent of any real, corporeal, existence.

    It seems (to me) certain that the idea of bodily survival after death was not the message that Jesus was trying to teach. Indeed, he explicitly scoffed at it (Matthew 22:23 ).  But the mistaken, the literal, interpretation proved enormously popular and, over the centuries, the idea of bodily survival was grafted onto the teaching of Jesus, and has brought many hopeful converts to Christianity. 

    Did the initial disciples of Jesus, by emphasising the empty tomb and the resurrection of Jesus, perpetrate a scam? Or were they honestly describing their experience? By 325 CE, when the bishops met at Nicea, politics seem to have dominated the discussion. For the Nicene Creed quite explicitly promises the resurrection of the dead [See References below].  

    Does Christianity (by which I mean, not the teaching of Jesus, but the more-or-less unified teaching of the Christian bishops in 325 CE) deliver any sort of 'Life after Death'? Perhaps yes, if you can believe and are inspired by the hope. But certainly no, if you cannot so believe. And nowadays many cannot. 

    By distinguishing between the teaching of Jesus and that of the Christian bishops, I have opened up the question -- was Jesus a Christian? I mean, could Jesus himself have subscribed to the Nicene or any other 'Christian' creed on the question of Life after Death; does the explicitly quoted teaching of Jesus promise anything like that which Christian Bishops have promised in his name? I think not. 

    If not, we may ask whether the explicit teaching of Jesus (such as we have) do better at delivering on its promises?

    Jesus is reported to have said that "God is not the God of the dead, but of the living." (Matth 22:32).  He is also reported as saying that the idea of meeting up with your spouse after death shows a misconception of Heaven; "Ye do err, not knowing the scriptures, nor the power of God. " (Matth 22:29 ).  Heaven is (he suggested) more like when a king prepares a wedding feast for his son, and sends out invitations, but the invitees do not come (Matth 22:3 ).   So he sends out invitations to all and any. (Matth 22: 9).  They come, but those that come to the party in the wrong frame of mind get nothing out of it. (Matth 22: 12).

    In this, was not Jesus saying something like: God is for the living, and Heaven is for the living, not for the dead. That we are invited to join him, in Heaven; so should we not attend? And if we accept the invitation, and go to the party, it surely behoves us to attend in the right frame of mind; count our blessings and feel glad to be there. 

    I feel the same way. I feel that to love creation with all one's heart, and with all one's mind (Matth.22:37), and to love and treat your neighbour as you treat yourself (Matth.22:39), creates a better world, an acceptable world, a world in which to be glad, in which to be grateful, and for which to wear festive clothes.  Even if plenty problems remain. 

    In that sense I find that Jesus delivers.


The part that dies and the part that lives on.

    To get anywhere in discussing the question of Life-after-Death, it is essential to be quite clear about the concepts of material reality and ideal thought. (The term 'Spirit' is undefined and is therefore avoided.) It is also essential to seek the truth, and embrace it.  

    Life, as far as I understand it, requires a flow of oxygen to the heart, and to the brain; without that flow, life and thought is impossible. 

    I attended a Quaker funeral at Whitley Bay Crematorium in 2008. One Quaker read a poem of Betty Walters about a leaf, containing the consoling idea that it, the leaf (i.e. the poet), might be reabsorbed back into 'God'. So I refrained from reading the poem of Francis Thompson that my mother had quoted as she prepared herself for death, though I think it excellently appropriate, and making a slightly different point – that birth implies death and death implies birth; "Nothing dies but something lives". 

    Instead, I found myself developing a thought I had started earlier in the day – that there are two parts to a person: a part that dies and a part that does not. What we love about a person is not a kilogram of cardiac muscle, or mushy liver. That, of course, is the part that dies. What we love is the husband, father, grandfather, the earner, the musician, the student, a smile, an anecdote; in fact more the idea of a person than the reality of a person. And that is the part that does not die, but lingers in the memories of the still-living. So, in effect, I have reached the conclusion that, to our emotions, a person (alive or dead) is more important as an 'idea' than as a 'thing'.

    I am not able to believe in Life Everlasting 'in the flesh', so get no comfort from the Christian promise, which (to me) is unsubstantiated, unlikely and unhelpful. But I do find some value in the undeniable fact that ideas about the good points of bygone people linger in the minds of the living; and may linger for a generation in most cases, and for two millennia in outstanding cases. In thus lingering, these memories support us in our endeavour 'to find heaven on earth'. 


References:

[1]  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato


Several 'Christian' Creeds

 (https://www3.nd.edu/~afreddos/courses/43801/creeds.pdf )

[2] "We look for the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come". (Nicene Creed, CE 325)

[3] "I believe in .... the resurrection of the body, and life everlasting." (Apostle's creed, c. CE 500, Wikipedia)

[4]  41. "At whose coming all men shall rise again with their bodies";

42.  "..and shall give account of their own works".

        43. "And they that have done good shall go into life everlasting and they that have done evil into everlasting fire."
        44. "This is the catholic faith, which except a man believe faithfully he cannot be saved." (Athanasian creed, c. CE 500, Wikipedia) 

01 December 2023

Palestine could lease land to Israel

Palestine could lease land to Israel.


Israeli settlements in the West Bank are deemed illegal. 

(The Palestinian West Bank is land taken by Israel by force in the war of 1967, and the Israeli presence is thus against International law. )

Israel covets that land.

(There are many Israelis who want to live in Arab land with such a fierce craving that they break the laws of normal civilised life in attempts to oust the Arab residents. The political majority in Israel condones that barbaric behaviour, thus showing itself not competent to govern the area.) 

Land purchases between states have been agreed in the past.

(Admittedly with mixed success. Florida was acquired off Spain in 1819 for $5million of settled citizen claims. In 1848, by the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, the USA paid Mexico $15million plus $3million in claims for 1,360,000 square km of land, i.e. Arizona, California, western Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, and Utah. The USA, in 1867, purchased Alaska off Russia at a fair price; $7.2million for 1.5million square km of land. Neither side particularly wanted the land.)

Could Israel occupy and enjoy Arab land legally? 

(Perhaps Israel could buy some land. But, if Palestine did not want to sell, perhaps they could agree to let out the land for an annual rent. Or negotiate a 99 year lease, as the British did with Hong Kong.)

Or are we living in a more barbaric, Post-Enlightenment, age?

20 November 2023

Is happiness elusive because mostly in the mind?

 To a pen-friend I was fated never to meet.

I think of myself as searching for a happiness which seems destined always to evade me. I wonder if that is because the happiness I seek is imaginary. 

In our heads we can piece together imaginary animals which can be thought of, but which could never exist; like centaurs with the body and legs of a horse. Similarly we can imagine a day of sunny summer weather, then add in a wonderful meal, a punt, my charming companion a gifted pianist. But poor old reality stumbles along, completely unable to keep up with the fantasy. There are empty beer cans on the grass, a fly in the ointment, and the pretty girl does not want to make love with me. 

Should I be content with the dream, or learn to be content with reality, and its empty beer cans? 

17 November 2023

Standing Charges for Energy

 Dear OFGEM,

You ask for feedback on the question of Standing Charges, (to the email address StandingCharges@ofgem.gov.uk.)
I have been against Standing Charges for a long time, both in regard to energy and water. There is, of course, a certain cost involved in connecting a house to the grid and in providing a meter, even when energy is not used. And some charge for those services is legitimate. (It cost a deal of money to build a car-making factory, a cost that is shared among those who buy cars, but not by is not imposed on those who do not buy cars.)
However, there is no reason why that standing energy charge should increase when the cost of fuel increases!!! It is clear that companies are using Standing Charges as a way to mislead customers into thinking that their electricity is cheaper than that of rivals, because their unit cost is cheaper. 
It is true that customers have no need to be fooled in this way; they can choose the company with the lowest standing charge (as indicating the most honest). Or they can do a more elaborate calculation using their own personal daily energy consumption.
There are two reasons why OFGEM might step in to moderate this ‘deceitfulness’. In a warming world with looming deadlines, there is some virtue in pressing down on the consumption of energy with a modest but consistent pressure. This effect is maximised when the standing charge is minimised.
For OFGEM to condone the practice of shunting some of the energy price rises into Standing-Charge-rises is to sully the reputation of OFGEM.
Yours sincerely, Ian West
Refs: 
[1] https://occidentis.blogspot.com/2022/09/standing-charges.html; 
[2] https://occidentis.blogspot.com/2022/10/average-electricity-consumption-part-2.html

(If you write to StandingCharges@ofgem.gov.uk, you might consider copying me in at: cawstein@gmail.com ) 

30 October 2023

Terrorism

Terrorism

My Shorter Oxford English Dictionary (1973) defines Terrorism as:

"Terrorism (te.roriz'm). 1795.  A system of terror. 1. Government by intimidation; the system of the 'Terror' (1793-4); see prec. 2. gen. A policy intended to strike with terror those against whom it is adopted; the fact of terrorizing or condition of being terrorized 1798." 

The term was invented by the French, and arose in the context of the French Revolution. 


My Collins English Dictionary (Millennium edition, 1998) has:

"terrorism (‘terǝ,rizəm) n 1 systematic use of violence and intimidation to achieve some goal. 2 the act of terrorizing. 3 the state of being terrorized. "


After the 11th September 2001 attack on the twin-towers of the World Trade Centre in New York the USA took up the word in a big way. But they found it necessary to narrow the definition to exclude their own governmental actions. Wikipedia is helpful here as they have a long article on "Terrorism". In that there is reference to the Cornell Law School's Legal Information Institute page on Title 22 Chapter 38 of the US Code, (https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/22/2656f) and their definition of terrorism:

"The term “terrorism” means premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by subnational groups or clandestine agents".


I think the crux of the criminal act of terrorism is fourfold:  (1) intimidation, for (2) purposes of control by means of acts of (3) violence against (4) noncombatant targets. I do not see that the size, or the political standing, of the perpetrator affects the criminality. 


The terrorism is extra annoying if the perpetrator is small; extra damaging if the perpetrator is large.


It is hard to see how the State of Israel (and also the USA, UK, etc.) can avoid the charge of being a Terrorist Organisation.

(Please tell me if you think I am wrong: Cawstein@gmail.com.)

20 October 2023

Failure to Understand the Benefits of Taxation

 Further to my post of 21 June 2023, which I hoped the Times would publish, I redrafted and sent the following to Professor William Davies who had just published an article on Inflation and Interest Rates in  the London Review of Books. 

Dear William Davies,

The rather rapid rise in interest rates in recent months is certainly putting a great strain on many young house-buyers. And it is generating a lot of comment in the media (by which I really mean Radio 4). Yet my analysis is completely different from that of the mainstream media. 

I believe a great deal of extra money was released into the economy during the COVID crisis, which must eventually cause inflation unless it is withdrawn. The fundamental dogma of the monetarists (that the value of money is set by the ratio of goods to cash) did not go away; it merely lay in wait. Devaluation (i.e.Inflation) would, in time, remove the extra money automatically, but is unfair in that if impoverishes those who hold or earn cash, but not those who hold assets. It is also destabilising, forcing a wage and price scramble.

The Bank of England is charged with suppressing inflation, but their standard (and perhaps only) means of doing so is to raise interest rates. This, however, is even more unfair than inflation/devaluation, as it enriches the rich and impoverishes the poor.  It is in any case ineffective while extra money is still sloshing around in the economy. 

By far the fairest means of getting the extra money out of the economy would have been by raising income tax rates. This, however, seems unthinkable in a democracy, because too few people understand the relationship between taxes and the benefits they fund (like roads, education, health, etc). Witness the surprising fact that every one of the candidates for the leadership of the Conservative party promised to degrade the quality of our public services, (entailed by cutting taxes).

Is this basically correct? And has anybody said it yet? I think not.

Please comment directly to Cawstein@gmail.com